从理想模型到建筑方案:边沁的两版全景监狱设计图研究

From Ideal Model to Architectural Plan: A Study of Two Versions of Bentham’s Panopticon Design

  • 摘要: 基于边沁1787年、1791年设计的两版全景监狱设计图,结合边沁的书信文稿与英国监狱改革的历史背景,通过比较研究,分析全景监狱的设计过程及设计思想。指出初版方案呈现了边沁的理想构思,是对监视原理与权力关系的空间化,适用于监狱和其他建筑类型。新版方案则是妥协的结果,在政府、社会的影响下背离了监视原则。然而,边沁的立场并未动摇,他对部分原则性话题避而不谈,甚至在图纸中隐藏了改动。本文强调建筑图像在表达设计思想和演变中的复杂性,突出将建筑图纸置于特定社会文化语境中的必要性,深化了对图像与思想之间复杂联系的理解。

     

    Abstract: Based on the two schemes of the Panopticon prison program, released in 1787 and 1791, in combination of an examination of Bentham’s epistolary corpus and the historical backdrop of British prison reform, this paper delves into the design evolution and conceptual underpinnings of the Panopticon through a comparative lens. The first version showcases Bentham’s utopian vision that articulates the spatialization of surveillance and the dynamics of the power relation. The subsequent version emerges as a compromise, one that yields to external pressures from government and society, deviating away from the cardinal principle of surveillance. Despite these concessions, Bentham’s core stance remains steadfast, evidenced by his subtle evasion of certain ideological pillars and even the concealment of alterations within the drawings. This paper underscores the intricacies of architectural images in conveying design philosophy and its evolution, emphasizing the paramount importance of interpreting architectural drawings within their specific socio-cultural milieu. It further fosters a deeper appreciation for the intricate interplay between visual representations and the ideas they encapsulate.

     

/

返回文章
返回